Advertisement

Johnny Depp’s Ebenezer Gets a ‘C’ From an Unnamed Insider

An unnamed insider says Ebenezer was Johnny Depp's big-screen test and earned a 'C'. The claim is unconfirmed; the box office figures are reported.
Johnny Depp: Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge at San Diego Comic Con 2026
Photo: Kevin Paul, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (cropped)
Advertisement

Quick summary

  • An unnamed industry insider has reportedly graded Johnny Depp‘s return in Ebenezer a “C”, according to CinemaBlend.
  • The claim comes from writer Rob Shuter‘s Substack, and it has not been confirmed by any studio.
  • CinemaBlend reports the film has made $43.4 million against a reported $38 million budget.
  • The same source suggests a return as Captain Jack Sparrow is now harder to justify. CinemaBlend advises treating that with caution.

An unnamed insider says Ebenezer was a test for Johnny Depp and that he passed, but only just. The claim was published on 18 November 2026 by CinemaBlend, which was passing on remarks first printed on Shuter’s Naughty But Nice Substack. It is a single anonymous opinion, not a studio verdict, and it should be read that way.

What the insider said

According to CinemaBlend, the source called the film “Johnny’s test” and said he “got a C”. The reasoning, as reported, is that a studio planning to spend heavily on a franchise needs more than a middling result. A flop would have let everyone move on, the source argued, while these numbers leave Hollywood with a harder choice.

CinemaBlend itself flags the quotes as something to take “with a grain of salt”. Neither the insider nor the studios behind the film are named, so none of it can be checked.

The numbers behind the grade

Ebenezer, directed by Ti West, is a screen version of the Dickens story with Depp in the title role. CinemaBlend says it opened at the top of the box office last weekend. At the time of writing, it reports a gross of $43.4 million on a reported budget of $38 million.

That puts the film ahead of its cost on paper, but not by a wide margin, and well short of the returns of Depp’s biggest hits. CinemaBlend notes the Pirates of the Caribbean films as the comparison. It also says Depp took a large pay cut to keep the budget low. Final results will depend on how the film holds up in the coming weeks.

Depp’s comeback in context

CinemaBlend describes Ebenezer as Depp’s return to a major English-language production. He stepped back from Hollywood, and from the United States, to seek privacy after the verdict in his defamation case against Amber Heard. His most recent screen role before this was in Jeanne du Barry, a French film made outside the Hollywood system.

He was also front and centre in the promotion, including a San Diego Comic-Con appearance dressed as Scrooge, the outlet says.

What the source says about Pirates

The insider described a new Pirates film as “the ultimate prize” for Depp. They said Hollywood first needs proof that audiences still want to see him, and that nostalgia alone will not sell hundreds of millions of dollars in tickets. No studio has announced a new Pirates project with Depp in this reporting. For more on the film’s opening, see our earlier look at the mixed weekend verdict.

What happens next

The next signal is the film’s second and third weekends, which will show whether the $43.4 million figure keeps climbing. Depp’s next project has not been announced in the sources reviewed. Everything we publish on the actor is gathered on our Johnny Depp page, and our Movies coverage tracks the wider box office.

Frequently asked questions

How much has Ebenezer made?

CinemaBlend reports $43.4 million at the time of writing, against a reported budget of $38 million.

Who gave Ebenezer a “C”?

An unnamed industry insider quoted on Rob Shuter’s Substack. The remark is unconfirmed and no studio has endorsed it.

Will Johnny Depp return as Captain Jack Sparrow?

Nothing has been announced. The insider suggests it is less likely after Ebenezer, but that is opinion, not a decision.

Sources

Advertisement

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

TRENDING NOW

Advertisement

LATEST

Advertisement

MORE LIKE THIS

Robert Pattinson: Robert Pattinson attends the "Primetime" Screening during the 83rd Venice International Film Festival at Sala Grande on September 05, 2026 in Venice, Italy

Robert Pattinson’s Rikers Island Visit and the Bond Link

Before Good Time, Robert Pattinson walked into Rikers Island in disguise. The Hollywood Reporter says the story shows why he
Sylvester Stallone: Sylvester Stallone

I Play Rocky Box Office: Stallone Biopic Eyes $12 Million

The Sylvester Stallone origin story I Play Rocky jumps from 29 screens to about 2,000 this weekend, with a $12
Street Fighter: Cody Rhodes Says The Rock Texted Him After Street Fighter Meeting

Cody Rhodes Says The Rock Texted Him After Street Fighter Meeting

Cody Rhodes says The Rock texted him straight after his Guile casting meeting for the new Street Fighter film, which
Seth Rogen: Seth Rogen attending the premiere of "The Invite" at the Sundance Film Festival

Seth Rogen on Cheering Up the 12 Years a Slave Cast

Seth Rogen says the 12 Years a Slave cast, including Brad Pitt, joined his This Is the End set in